The Triton


Owner sues over failed engine


American yacht owner Michael Hirtenstein has sued his London-based lawyers after a yacht he bought, the 149-foot (45m) M/Y Candyscape, lost an engine an hour after closing the deal.

He bought the yacht in July 2010 for 4.5 million euros at what he thought was a steal, according to a news report in the UK’s The Independent newspaper.

The case has wound up in London’s High Court, where Hill Dickinson is being sued for not obtaining a guarantee over the condition of the yacht, the newspaper reported.

The yacht, now called M/Y Il Sole, has since had a $2.5 million refit and replacement of both engines.

According to the newspaper Hill Dickinson arranged the purchase and had assured Hirtenstein that it came with a personal guarantee. However, after a two-week hearing in August, a High Court judge ruled that no such guarantee existed.

While Hill Dickinson was liable for legal negligence, which the firm accepted, Hirtenstein was only awarded “nominal damages”. A hearing in October will determine what those costs are.

Hill Dickinson released this statement to the newspaper: “Hill Dickinson regrets that a mistake was made in this matter. The firm highlighted the error to the client as soon as it came to their attention and was satisfied that it had caused the client no loss. This position has been vindicated in the judgment.”

Related Articles

After storm, marina manager has new job

After storm, marina manager has new job

Megan Mills, formerly the marina manager at Treasure Cay Marina in the Abacos, is now the marina supervisor at Romora Bay Resort and Marina. Marc Tonis, right, is Romora’s assistant general …

Elario joins Northrop & Johnson

Elario joins Northrop & Johnson

Veteran charter and sales broker Steve Elario has joined the Fort Lauderdale office of Northrop & Johnson. Originally from Newburyport, Mass., Elario started in yachting as a deckhand in the …

Strict rules on fuel cleanliness mean more work for filters

Strict rules on fuel cleanliness mean more work for filters

It is a common belief that the diesel engine fuel filter, installed by the engine manufacturer, will provide the required level of contamination protection to achieve reliable operation. This is a …

Managers merge

Managers merge

Ft. Lauderdale-based yacht management company Edge Yachts has acquired industry veteran Water’s Edge Consulting from its founder, Ken Argent. Company CEO Anthony Sands founded the company three …

Latest news in the charter fleet: Icon in the Med, Rebel in the Bahamas

Latest news in the charter fleet: Icon in the Med, Rebel in the Bahamas

M/Y Icon, a 221-foot (67.5m) Icon yacht built in 2010, will be available for charter in the western Med next summer through Bluewater Yachting. M/Y Rebel, a 157-foot (48m) Trinity built in 2005, …

First day challenges for stews

Before starting a new job, learn why the position is available. It’s possible that a new role has just been created or, just as likely, someone left and needs to be replaced. If the latter is …


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please answer the question below to leave a comment. * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.