The Triton


Captains choose job for best fit, not just owner or salary


There’s a difference between taking a job and choosing a job. As the yachting industry gets busy cruising again, there seem to be more captains moving around. It’s less about needing a job, it seems, and more about landing a good one.

Many times, of course, the choice is easy, depending on how long they have been on the dock. But captains gathered for our August roundtable discussion said they are far enough along in their career to be a little more selective about job offers. And while their impressions of the owner and the salary play a part, they agreed there’s other stuff more important to them now.

“I’ve turned down three positions in the past eight months,” said one captain. “I’m honest with the owner and we agree it’s not a good fit. I have a two-way interview and interview them as much as they do me. The best part is when they ask if I have any questions and I pull my list out. I want to know what the program is, what the benefits are, who hires and fires, and how they handle crew. I’ve been stuck with crew I can’t fire.”

“Nothing’s worse than that,” another captain said. “It doesn’t end well.

“It doesn’t end well because you end up emasculated in front of other crew, and pretty soon this one is getting away with stuff, and then this one, and that one,” the first captain said. “Where do you go from there? You end up looking for another job.”

As always, individual comments are not attributed to any one person in particular so as to encourage frank and open discussion. The attending captains are identified in a photograph here.

Attendees of The Triton’s August Bridge luncheon were, from left, Bernard Calot (freelance), Michael Bain of M/Y Huey’s Island, Caleb Semtner of M/Y Brio, Mark Howard, Ian Stuart of M/Y Nine Stars, Herb Magney of M/Y Island Heiress and Scott Redlhammer (freelance). PHOTO/LUCY REED

Attendees of The Triton’s August Bridge luncheon were, from left, Bernard Calot (freelance), Michael Bain of M/Y Huey’s Island, Caleb Semtner of M/Y Brio, Mark Howard, Ian Stuart of M/Y Nine Stars, Herb Magney of M/Y Island Heiress and Scott Redlhammer (freelance). PHOTO/LUCY REED

The captains shared their stories of inherited crew and they agreed that they often resist jobs where the owner participates in crew management decisions. Another deal breaker is salaries.

“Before the interview, I have to know they’re going to pay industry standard,” one captain said. “I’ve wasted so much time and miles on my car to get to interviews only to be told they don’t. Crew agencies lead me down the wrong path.”

“Is it their job to negotiate your salary or put you up for a job?” another captain said.

“Point taken,” said the first.

But beyond the money is how the owner funds the boat.

“For me, it’s not the salary, it’s the operating budget of the boat,” a captain said. “That’s what I like to pin down. What is the budget in terms of how we handle safety issues and class? And who hires crew? I work for you; the crew works for me. You don’t need to be involved in the issues of time off and crew. I’ll decide with you what you want to offer and then disseminate that to the crew. The last thing I want is for the owner to come on the boat and get cornered by some stew or deckhand wanting a week off.”

The reputation of the yacht and its owner can play a part in a job choice, too, but not as much as I thought.

“If it [the boat] changes owners, it’s easier,” one captain said. “I was up for a job on a bad rep boat that sold. I spent the day with the owner and he was a really nice guy, so I took the job.”

What do you do when it’s not a new owner?

“You don’t take the job,” several captains said in unison.

“That one’s for the watch-standing guy who wants his first captain’s job,” one captain said.

“We all paid our dues working for guys we didn’t like,” another said.

“I was warned about it [a boat with a bad reputation] but I needed the job,” said a third. “A boat’s reputation sometimes rubs off on the captain.”

“Only to those who don’t know you,” said another captain. “If we’ve done this for a while, there’s no defense with people who say something about you. You have your own reputation, and the people who know you know you.”

The captains were confident in their ability to talk to owners frankly.

“My relationship is with the owner,” one captain said. “I once worked for a guy who was very difficult. I said to him in the interview — I heard about you. If you hire me, this is what’s going to happen. You have a problem; you are afraid to lose your money and you don’t trust anyone.”

I must have raised my eyebrows at that because several other captains came to his defense and said similar things.

“You have nothing to lose but the job you don’t have,” another captain said about being honest in an interview.

“Owners actually love that,” said a third. “They like to say ‘He’s rude to me but he’s incredibly efficient.’ One of his captains stayed 25 years. It’s a compliment that you can work with a guy for 25 years that you don’t get along with.”

“I only stayed three years,” the first captain said. “I bit my tongue, learned about budgets, got raped on salary, and when it was over, I got a ton of offers. I guess they figured ‘If you can put up with that…’.”

In the grand scheme of things, the days may be gone where one job makes a career. So, depending on what’s important to captains at the time, they will choose their command for different reasons.

“I turned down a couple before I took this job,” one captain said. “I’m looking 10 years down the road. I will take a shittier job on a nicer boat, for now. Once I get my unlimited license, I’ll be looking for the best income and life choices.”

In this delicate balance of relationships, I was curious about captains who take positions without ever having met the owner. Most captains in the room had taken jobs after a phone conversation, and several had taken over boats in what they called rescue missions.

“i’m doing the job for someone affiliated with the boat,” one captain said. “I’m doing a favor for them.”

“It’s like a delivery,” said another. “Do you meet the owner on a delivery?”

“Or even see the boat?” said a third.

“You roll the dice,” the other captain said. “And not everybody is geared for that.”

“Some of the rescue missions, you don’t feel like you’ve committed to them,” a captain said. “You can interview them for a couple of months.”

“It gives you a different leverage,” another said.

“It worked out great for me; I got good experiences,” said a third. “Even if it’s not for me, I might know someone whose saddle will fit.”

There’s a captain for every owner, they agreed.

Lucy Chabot Reed is editor of The Triton. Comments on this story are welcome at If you make your living working as a yacht captain, e-mail us for an invitation to our monthly Bridge luncheon.


About Lucy Chabot Reed

Lucy Chabot Reed is publisher and founding editor of The Triton.

View all posts by Lucy Chabot Reed →

Related Articles

St. Lucia expects record number of yachts

St. Lucia expects record number of yachts

Marigot Bay Marina on St. Lucia expects more visiting yachts this season than in previous years, according to marina manager Troy Blanchard. The marina saw record numbers of yachts in 2017, when …

Triton survey: Have you worked with a captain you doubted?

I recently met a crew member who told me a terrible story of a delivery. A lifelong sailor and a tall, strong young man, he admitted he was afraid on that trip. The captain wasn’t prepared, and …

FLIBS19: SuperYacht Village comes to life

FLIBS19: SuperYacht Village comes to life

The new SuperYacht Village was abuzz yesterday as swarms of crew working on the largest boats in the show made their way with flowers, decorations, provisions and, of course, chamois mops. Find …

YMB17: Miami hosts two boat shows this week

YMB17: Miami hosts two boat shows this week

Relocation, expansions, renaming and redesigns have caused a bit of confusion regarding the “Miami boat show”. Actually, there are two boat shows taking place in Miami this week: the 29th …

Crew Coach: Not listening biggest part of communication breakdown

Crew Coach: Not listening biggest part of communication breakdown

Crew Coach: by Capt. Rob Gannon Good communication – healthy communication – is so important to relationships, both professional and personal, yet it remains elusive and a struggle for many. …

Crew Coach: De-escalation skills crucial when confronted by angry clients

Crew Coach: De-escalation skills crucial when confronted by angry clients

Crew Coach: by Capt. Rob Gannon Sometimes when working with or just dealing with other people, we encounter the annoyed, disappointed, possibly going-off-the rails client or charter guest. How we …


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please answer the question below to leave a comment. * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.