Write to Be Heard: Troubling rape verdict raises awareness

Mar 27, 2018 by Alene Keenan

By Alene Keenan

I would like to comment regarding last month’s article about the rape lawsuit on M/Y Endless Summer. I think that most people have great compassion for the young woman who was brutalized, but I have heard some incredibly insensitive and inappropriate remarks, too.

Several people said they are not surprised, or they wonder how many times a similar incident has happened and not been reported. Sometimes the victim doesn’t want to say anything, or God forbid, tattle on a co-worker, but this is a serious crime that should be reported. Thank goodness somebody stepped up to the plate.

People would be shocked to learn about the negative and unpleasant aspects of the yachting industry. Many would agree that it was just a matter of time until someone filed charges of this nature and brought the dark underbelly of yachting out into the open. Sailors are known to like their drink, but the social acceptance of alcohol abuse allows us to ignore its dangers. Many boats never adopt an alcohol control policy, and if they do they don’t always enforce it. We can’t expect the security guard at the gate to determine the sobriety and health of crew as they come back to the boat.

The captain sets the tone and social structure on a yacht. The owner relies on the person they hired to steer them in the right direction. In this case, perhaps the owner was negligent for not taking the reasonable steps to perform due diligence regarding the captain, the crew, and the safety of the working conditions of the boat. I wonder if a background check for the crew would have made a difference in the outcome. Would a personality test have revealed that the deckhand was a vicious rapist?

The charge of negligence is understandable, however, due to the regrettable fact that attorneys for the owner denied the claims, stating that the woman “failed to exercise ordinary care, caution or prudence for her own welfare.” This unashamedly disregards this young woman’s rights and safety, implying that she was somehow responsible for the rape. The person who committed this crime has been charged, served a sentence and been deported back to his home country, but she will forever bear the burden of an attack that she did not deserve. Rape is a violation of human rights. It’s not about sex, it’s about violence and power.

The case created public record with evidence on both sides, and the jury took the side of the young victim. Running with a skeleton crew of two or three people of different genders and level of experience in the shipyard is not always a good idea. The issue of safety on board was key, and it was clear that the safety of the crew was compromised. To make matters worse, maintenance and cure after the attack was denied. But the jury held the owner accountable. They decided that someone would answer for this, and they decided the amount of money in this case — a big number that got a lot of attention.

Of course, it’s not about the money. No amount of money will give this young woman the life she had before; no amount of money will give her back her dreams and her innocence.

On the other hand, it is about the money. Perhaps the award against the owner is troubling, but maybe this a wake-up call to the industry. People are paying attention now, and this incident is raising awareness. Owners will want to know what is happening on their yachts and what they should do to be involved in establishing policies and regulations to ensure a respectful working environment, safe manning laws and safe working practices.

Thank goodness there are so many wonderful captains out there who run a tight ship. Yachting can’t be compared to an office-based business, because things are very different when people live where they work. You can’t make everyone safe from everyone else all the time, but the captain can create a culture of safety onboard and take control of disrespectful behavior that uses misogynistic language and attitudes that objectify women.

I am so sorry for what this young woman has been through, sorry for the whole situation, but more than anything I am grateful to have had the opportunity to work with some great captains in my career. I have hope that this will raise awareness and create a stronger industry going forward.

Alene Keenan is lead instructor of yacht interior courses at Maritime Professional Training in Ft. Lauderdale. She has more than 20 years experience as a yacht stew.


Related Articles

Ship’s Cook Certificate requirements due Feb. 15

International regulations can take time to filter down to the yachting industry, and such is the case with the Ship’s Cook Certificate (SCC). It is only required for a

Triton Spotter: Atlanta Boat Show

Triton Spotter: Atlanta Boat Show

The Triton was spotted at the Atlanta Boat Show in January with David Prince, owner of Grass Shack at Lake Lanier, along with Mike Moulder of Keller Williams Chattahoochee

Meet Triton Networking host Admiral Canvas

Meet Triton Networking host Admiral Canvas

Keep your networking momentum going by joining us on the first Wednesday in November — just days after the Fort Lauderdale boat show — for Triton Networking with Admiral

Triton Survey: Captains ready to move, many plans still on hold

Triton Survey: Captains ready to move, many plans still on hold

By Lucy Chabot Reed As government and port lockdowns stretch into their third month, many yachts and crew that have had to stay put can’t help but wonder about

West Marine welcomes new CEO

West Marine welcomes new CEO

California-based boating retailer West Marine has hired Doug Robinson as CEO. Robinson has 30 years of specialty retailing experience, most recently with Lowe’s, where he was president of …

Tender dealer gets honored

South Florida-based watersports retailer Nautical Ventures has received The Best International Dealer Award from Helsinki-based Axopar Boats during its recent international dealer meeting. Axopar …