A captain may be responsible for the yacht, its safety, and its operation, but managing the people on board can be one of the most unpredictable parts of the job. From a crewmember walking off mid-trip to burnout, performance problems, and disagreements with ownership, captains often find themselves managing situations no training course can fully prepare them for.

For Capt. Jordan Walker, who has run an 82-foot Princess for more than a decade, leadership starts with teamwork. On a smaller private yacht, there may not be multiple people in every department, so his crew is cross-trained and expected to step in wherever needed.

“I want us to be the biggest small yacht around,” Walker said. “I expect the standards to rival the best and I will make sure they are rewarded as such.”

Walker also encourages crew to contribute ideas and credits supportive owners with helping create an environment where hard work is recognized. When responsibilities are handled, crew may be included in activities such as fishing or island outings, reinforcing the sense that everyone is part of the program.

Upholding those standards becomes more difficult when crew get too comfortable. Walker said that staying out late, drinking, or arriving unprepared can leave others picking up the slack. Over time, that can affect both performance and morale.

For Walker, that makes checking in with crew important. Captains need to recognize when something is wrong, professionally or personally, while remembering that crewmembers spend long periods away from home, family, and major life events.

Capt. Mark McDowell has seen those challenges from numerous perspectives during his 23 years in yachting. McDowell believes one of the biggest lessons in crew management is recognizing that the same approach will not work for everyone.

“That’s the beauty of leadership management: understanding every single one of these crewmembers is different,” McDowell said.

His own approach was shaped over years of watching other leaders, both good and bad, and learning from his own mistakes. McDowell believes leadership and management training should begin earlier in a crewmember’s career, rather than waiting until someone reaches a senior position.

That experience becomes particularly important when a crewmember unexpectedly leaves. McDowell recalled a recent situation involving a chef who was no longer working well. Rather than immediately making a personnel change, he first tried to understand what was happening.

“If you don’t have a conversation and ask them what’s going on, you’re definitely not going to resolve the situation anyway,” McDowell said.

When it became clear the situation could not be resolved, management was informed, a replacement was sought, and the team adjusted. Whether guests are informed, he said, depends largely on how directly the departure affects their experience. A chef leaving during guest use, for example, is considerably more visible than losing someone working behind the scenes.

How much freedom a captain has to make those decisions also depends on the program. McDowell said captains remain ultimately responsible, but management companies and owners can have significant influence. Trust and longevity within a program can also affect how much autonomy a captain has.

The challenge is knowing when to listen and when a decision simply must be made.

“Ultimately, the buck does stop with me, and I have to make the final decision,” McDowell said.

Burnout adds another layer. Long hours, confined living spaces, and extended periods of guest use can test even strong teams. McDowell said supportive owners and management can make a significant difference, particularly when crew need time to recover after demanding trips.

Clear expectations also help prevent problems before they escalate. McDowell favors standing orders and an established chain of command, giving crew a reference point for what is expected while still allowing concerns to move up the hierarchy when necessary.

Both captains see communication as central to maintaining that balance. Walker emphasizes creating a team where crewmembers help one another, while McDowell believes leaders must adapt to the individuals they manage rather than expecting every person to respond the same way.

Experience has also taught McDowell that command does not mean having every answer. He regularly turns to other captains and mentors for perspective and encourages newer captains to do the same.

“Sometimes you need to ask for help,” McDowell said. “You don’t know everything.”

Walker’s approach brings the lesson back to the people behind the operation.

“I believe it’s important for a captain to keep an eye on his crew and check in on them, making sure they’re alright on a personal level,” Walker said.

Ultimately, managing a successful crew requires more than authority. Communication, consistency, adaptability, and knowing when to listen can be just as important as knowing when to take command.